Metals industry surging in Russia; analysts concerned

Wearing fireproof coveralls, Ilya Dmitriyev plodded past a smelter that belched smoke and gushed molten metal, the chief product of this gritty patch of Arctic tundra where the air tastes of sulphur and concrete apartment blocks crumble on the shifting permafrost. This is the home of Norilsk Nickel, a former slave labour camp – once part of Stalin's infamous gulag – that is now the gray capital of Russia's glittering new metals empire. Since President Vladimir Putin came to power in 2000, oil and natural gas have fueled Russia's economic rebirth, creating a generation of young Russian billionaires. Now metal is the latest natural resource bonanza for Russia. The rise of the industry has delighted investors but has caused disquiet among foreign security analysts. Some fear Moscow might use its vast mineral wealth as a tool for coercive diplomacy, the way many believe the Kremlin has used oil and gas supplies to punish former Soviet nations that lean toward the West. As the output of Chinese and Indian factories surged last year, the price of nickel jumped 64 percent to an average of $24,155 per ton on the London Metal Exchange, more than doubling Norilsk Nickel's profits. While the price has retreated from a high of more than $50,000 per ton in May, it now trades at around $29,000 a ton. Workers like Dmitriyev have benefited. Wages at Norilsk rose 40 percent in April, and Norilsk's smelter workers now earn about $1,500 a month – triple the national average. But the big winners at Norilsk are the company's two 40-something shareholders, Vladimir Potanin and Mikhail Prokhorov. In the past year, their personal fortunes more than doubled, to more than $13.5 billion each, according to Forbes magazine. Russia's top five metals magnates – including Potanin and Prokhorov – saw their combined value jump 70 percent last year, to $66 billion, Forbes said. Through Norilsk, these two men control half of the world's output of palladium, which is used in catalytic converters, and one fifth of its nickel, which is a crucial ingredient in stainless steel. Prices have risen sharply for most metals that Russia produces, not just nickel. Copper is up 30 percent this year. Average aluminium prices rose 36 percent last year and the metal is trading 8 percent above the 2006 average. Iron ore prices have doubled in the past three years. Meanwhile, low electricity rates and wages in Russia have made mining companies more profitable than their competitors abroad. The mineral wealth of Russia has few rivals. A local legend says that as God scattered riches around the world, his hands froze when he came to Norilsk and he dropped everything that he was carrying. Record profits have driven a wave of acquisitions. Of the $9.5 billion spent on acquisitions by Russian companies last year, metals companies accounted for 84 percent, according to the magazine Russian Mergers & Acquisitions. This year, that figure could double. In June, Norilsk acquired control of a Canadian mining operation, LionOre, in a $6.4 billion deal – the largest-ever Russian purchase overseas. The deal adds nickel mines and processing plants in Australia, South Africa and Botswana to the company's portfolio. Norilsk also controls Stillwater Mining of Montana, the only U.S. platinum and palladium miner. This year it paid $408 million for the Cleveland-based OM Group's nickel assets in Australia and Finland. Created to strengthen Stalin's Soviet Union, Norilsk Nickel – like so many Soviet mammoths – was sold for a song by President Boris Yeltsin to politically connected bankers in the 1990s. But analysts praise Potanin and Prokhorov for streamlining a sprawling, debt-laden colossus into a modern multinational. The company controls mines and refineries in eight countries and employs tens of thousands of workers across the globe. But it is just one of Russia's metals titans. More than 12 percent of global aluminium output comes from the privately owned UC Russian Aluminum, one of the world's biggest producers of the vital metal. State-owned mines and stockpiles in Russia account for 20 percent of the world's uranium, more than any single country. A mining company controlled by the state arms exporter, Rosoboronexport, is the world's biggest producer of titanium. Without titanium from the Russian company VSMPO-Avisma, Boeing's 787 Dreamliner and Airbus's A350 XWB could not fly, analysts say. The metal is also critical to Lockheed Martin's F-35 Joint Strike Fighter, an advanced fighter bomber being jointly developed by Britain and the United States. In the West, there is quiet concern that Russia will use its clout in the metals market to help consolidate its geopolitical power. "Due to Russia's actions on the nonferrous metals markets, there have been claims of manipulation or dubious behaviour," Robert Larsson of the Swedish Defense Research Agency wrote in a report. "As the sector by and large is shielded from insight and data are secret or unreliable, it is hard to assess, but it is clear that Russia's impact on the markets is substantial." Prokhorov has pledged to sell his stake by the end of the year to Potanin, his long-time business partner. That would give Potanin 52 percent of the company, and he has said it would not be "a tragedy" if the government bought up Norilsk. Prokhorov's withdrawal was announced shortly after the French police detained him at a posh Alpine ski resort in France on suspicion of involvement in a prostitution ring. In the end, no charges were filed, but the incident became tabloid fodder in Russia and abroad. He left his post as general director in April. The company said Prokhorov had long planned to sell his stake, but industry watchers suspect the Kremlin used the case to force Prokhorov out. "Norilsk clearly stands out as one of Russia's strategically important companies, where the state doesn't have a significant equity stake," said Chris Weafer, chief strategist with Moscow's Alfa Bank. That could change, he said: "Rather than sitting in the Kremlin saying 'this is what we would like you to do,' it's much better to sit on the board and say 'this is what we're going to do."